Across all of my classes, I teach hundreds of college students a semester. I also run a private therapy practice, which is what shows up on this blog. People tend to assume those are two unrelated jobs, which seems a little strange to me. They are not really that separate at all, and the overlap has taught me a lot about high-achieving adults.
Let me explain this connection a little bit more because I think I might have lost you. I watch students do the same things when a question doesn’t have a clean answer that I watch accomplished adults do in my office when their life stops following the specific plan they envisioned and set for themselves. Different settings, but there is a very similar response to change and uncertainty.
In class
The students who struggle most are rarely the ones who cannot do the work, although sometimes there are more factors at play than what I am talking about today. The students struggling the most are often the ones who are the sharpest. What trips them up is that they have almost no tolerance for not knowing, and that seems to be getting worse as we use technology. I won’t go too deep into that right now, but that is a huge rant likely coming in the future. When something is ambiguous, a grade is uncertain, or a topic will not resolve into a single right answer they can memorize, they have an absolute freak out. Not knowing feels like failing. That is really sad to me because not knowing is a key part of the road to success. We also learn a whole lot more from messing up and trying until we get it right than getting it right the first time.
These students typically do one of two things. They over-prepare to the point of exhaustion, trying to eliminate any chance of being incorrect or unsure, running themselves into the ground. Or they avoid by not starting the paper or not turning it in, because in their minds a thing you never attempted cannot officially be a thing you failed at. And for them, failure is the single most terrifying outcome they can think of.
You can see how well that usually works out.
As a full fledged adult
Those types of students I see in class grow into the adults I see in session. The pattern does not go away once they graduate. It just gets even stronger in adult life because they never learned to do anything different. And we know that the more we practice something, the stronger the association and the better we get at it.
The over-preparer becomes the type of professional who cannot delegate or rest, and treats every unknown as a threat. They are seen as incredibly successful and praised for their hard work, but inside they feel like a failure because nothing is ever one hundred percent certain, which is their threshold for success. The avoider becomes the person who struggles to make decisions, avoids the conversation, or avoids the risk that actually matters to them, and calls it being careful. They always wonder why they never seem to reach their potential. Underneath both is what I see in the classroom: perfection used as protection. They think, “If I do it flawlessly, or if I do not do it at all, no one gets to see my failures.”
This is not a moral failing, and it is not the generational problem people reach for when they want an easy explanation. I will say, though, that the increased speed of technology has made us all way less comfortable with waiting, and the constant success of others broadcast in our face can make us feel even more inadequate. Regardless, it is a learned strategy for avoiding one specific feeling, and the feeling is usually something related to being judged or determined a failure.
What helps
I am not telling you to lower your standards. Capable people hear what I said above and think it means dropping success and rightly reject it, because their standards are part of who they are and part of why they are good at what they do. You just don’t have to approach success the same way you have been.
What helps is building the one skill that you were never explicitly taught. You must learn to tolerate not knowing. That is it. Staying in the uncertainty long enough to realize it’s not the end of the world, instead of sprinting to make the discomfort go away. This is something we can work on; it’s not easy, but it’s something that can be learned.
The other piece is separating your performance from your worth. When those two come apart, the standards stay and the panic stops running your whole life. The goal isn’t to care less, it’s being able to do things when not all parts are known.
If this sounds like you
If you read this and thought, " That is me, both the student version and the grown-up one.” Cool, you are exactly who I work with! The people who do best with me are usually driven, capable people who are tired of how much energy they are using up trying to make the unknown known, and are ready to put in the effort up front to change the way that they approach life.
Reach out so we can see if we are a good fit to help set you free from this cycle.